Manufacturing's Turnover Challenge: Strategies for Retaining Talent and Ensuring Compliance

Margaret Genatios • March 26, 2025
A production manager reviewing hiring documents with an employee in a factory setting

Introduction: The Manufacturing Turnover Challenge

The manufacturing industry is a cornerstone of the U.S. economy, yet it faces a persistent challenge: high employee turnover. Recent data indicates that the manufacturing sector experiences a turnover rate of approximately 28.6%, significantly above the national average of 3.6%.

This elevated turnover not only disrupts production but also complicates compliance efforts, particularly concerning the accurate completion and management of Form I-9, essential for verifying the employment eligibility of new hires.


Understanding Turnover in the Manufacturing Industry

Several factors contribute to the high turnover rates within manufacturing::

  • Lack of Communication: Poor transparency about pay and company health increases turnover.
  • Limited Appreciation: Employees feeling undervalued are more likely to leave.
  • Burnout: Overworking leads to dissatisfaction and exits.
  • Stagnant Growth: Without development opportunities, employees seek advancement elsewhere.


These factors necessitate robust strategies to manage turnover effectively while ensuring compliance with employment verification requirements.

Strategies for I-9 Compliance in Manufacturing Organizations

  1. Timely Completion of Form I-9

Ensure that Section 1 of Form I-9 is completed by the employee no later than their first day of employment and that the employer finalizes Section 2 within three business days. Implementing a standardized onboarding process can facilitate adherence to these timelines.

  2. Regular Training for HR Personal

Provide ongoing training sessions for HR staff to stay updated on the latest I-9 regulations and procedures. This is particularly crucial in high-turnover environments to maintain consistency and compliance.

  3. Conduct Internal Audits

Regularly auditing I-9 forms can help identify and rectify errors proactively, reducing the risk of non-compliance during external inspections.

  4. Leverage E-Verify

Enrolling in E-Verify allows organizations to confirm the employment eligibility of new hires electronically, adding an extra layer of verification to the I-9 process.

  5. Implement Digital Solutions

Leveraging digital tools for I-9 management can streamline the process, reduce errors, and ensure secure storage of sensitive information.


Enhancing Compliance with Clear I-9

Managing I-9 compliance amidst high turnover can be challenging, but Clear I-9 offers a comprehensive solution tailored to the unique needs of the manufacturing industry.


Key Benefits of Clear I-9: 

  • Automated Workflows: Streamline the I-9 process, reducing manual effort and minimizing errors.
  • Real-Time Validation: Instantly verify employee information to ensure accuracy and compliance.
  • Live  I-9 Video Verifications: Facilitate remote verification processes, essential for organizations with geographically dispersed teams.
  • Secure Document Storage: Maintain all I-9 forms in a secure, centralized repository, ensuring easy access during audits.
  • Regulatory Updates: Stay informed with automatic updates on the latest I-9 regulations, ensuring your organization remains compliant.


Stay Compliant and Retain Your Workforce

In an industry where workforce stability is crucial, compliance shouldn’t be an added burden. Clear I-9 ensures every hire is verified quickly, securely, and compliantly—so you can focus on retaining your talent and maintaining production efficiency.



Schedule a demo today and strengthen your compliance strategy!



Have Questions or Need More Information?

A warehouse manager reviewing hiring documents, ensuring compliance / efficient worforce.
By Margaret Genatios March 12, 2025
Retail and wholesale employers face high turnover, making I-9 compliance complex. Seasonal hiring and frequent workforce changes create risks of errors, fines, and audits. Learn best practices for timely I-9 completion, internal audits, and the benefits of digital verification tools like Clear I-9 to simplify compliance and reduce administrative burden.
The importance of athletes ensuring I-9 compliance for teams and organizations
By Margaret Genatios March 4, 2025
High turnover in the sports industry makes I-9 compliance a challenge. Clear I-9 automates verification, reduces errors, and ensures seamless hiring. Stay compliant with fast, secure, and digital I-9 management.
More Posts
Share by: