Manufacturing's Turnover Challenge: Strategies for Retaining Talent and Ensuring Compliance

Margaret Genatios • March 26, 2025
A production manager reviewing hiring documents with an employee in a factory setting

Introduction: The Manufacturing Turnover Challenge

The manufacturing industry is a cornerstone of the U.S. economy, yet it faces a persistent challenge: high employee turnover. Recent data indicates that the manufacturing sector experiences a turnover rate of approximately 28.6%, significantly above the national average of 3.6%.

This elevated turnover not only disrupts production but also complicates compliance efforts, particularly concerning the accurate completion and management of Form I-9, essential for verifying the employment eligibility of new hires.


Understanding Turnover in the Manufacturing Industry

Several factors contribute to the high turnover rates within manufacturing::

  • Lack of Communication: Poor transparency about pay and company health increases turnover.
  • Limited Appreciation: Employees feeling undervalued are more likely to leave.
  • Burnout: Overworking leads to dissatisfaction and exits.
  • Stagnant Growth: Without development opportunities, employees seek advancement elsewhere.


These factors necessitate robust strategies to manage turnover effectively while ensuring compliance with employment verification requirements.

Strategies for I-9 Compliance in Manufacturing Organizations

  1. Timely Completion of Form I-9

Ensure that Section 1 of Form I-9 is completed by the employee no later than their first day of employment and that the employer finalizes Section 2 within three business days. Implementing a standardized onboarding process can facilitate adherence to these timelines.

  2. Regular Training for HR Personal

Provide ongoing training sessions for HR staff to stay updated on the latest I-9 regulations and procedures. This is particularly crucial in high-turnover environments to maintain consistency and compliance.

  3. Conduct Internal Audits

Regularly auditing I-9 forms can help identify and rectify errors proactively, reducing the risk of non-compliance during external inspections.

  4. Leverage E-Verify

Enrolling in E-Verify allows organizations to confirm the employment eligibility of new hires electronically, adding an extra layer of verification to the I-9 process.

  5. Implement Digital Solutions

Leveraging digital tools for I-9 management can streamline the process, reduce errors, and ensure secure storage of sensitive information.


Enhancing Compliance with Clear I-9

Managing I-9 compliance amidst high turnover can be challenging, but Clear I-9 offers a comprehensive solution tailored to the unique needs of the manufacturing industry.


Key Benefits of Clear I-9: 

  • Automated Workflows: Streamline the I-9 process, reducing manual effort and minimizing errors.
  • Real-Time Validation: Instantly verify employee information to ensure accuracy and compliance.
  • Live  I-9 Video Verifications: Facilitate remote verification processes, essential for organizations with geographically dispersed teams.
  • Secure Document Storage: Maintain all I-9 forms in a secure, centralized repository, ensuring easy access during audits.
  • Regulatory Updates: Stay informed with automatic updates on the latest I-9 regulations, ensuring your organization remains compliant.


Stay Compliant and Retain Your Workforce

In an industry where workforce stability is crucial, compliance shouldn’t be an added burden. Clear I-9 ensures every hire is verified quickly, securely, and compliantly—so you can focus on retaining your talent and maintaining production efficiency.



Schedule a demo today and strengthen your compliance strategy!



Have Questions or Need More Information?

Veteran being hired by HR professional, representing inclusive WOTC hiring.
By HRlogics July 10, 2025
Explore the future of WOTC beyond 2025, including potential expansions, legislation updates, and how HRlogics helps businesses maximize this tax credit.
Two employees in a collaborative workspace viewing a digital employment verification on a laptop.
By HRlogics July 8, 2025
Empower employees with My Verify. Reduce HR workload, improve compliance, and accelerate employment verifications across your organization.
More Posts